Containment Fail

We want to share a few observations about the growing COVID-19 epidemic, based on what we have seen so far. It has been obvious for a while now that the attempt to contain the spread of the virus has essentially failed. Ever since case numbers started to soar in South Korea, Italy and Iran, it was clear that hopes that the outbreak would remain confined to China were misplaced.


Doubleplus-ungood micro-organism COVID-19 looking for cells to infect


While it appears that the draconian measures taken by China’s government have managed to slow the spread of the infection in the country substantially (the caveat is that it is hard to say how reliable the data released by China are), the outbreak is accelerating everywhere else. It does not appear to be containable, we therefore expect governments will begin to adopt mitigation strategies.

At the time of writing the chart depicting total cases outside of China looked like this:


Total cases outside of China; at first the growth rate seemed manageable, but not anymore. A comprehensive up-to-date collection of COVID-19-related charts and data is available here.


Known and Unknown Problems

This is the situation as we see it:

1. it is now an out-of-control pandemic, regardless of what the WHO wants to call it, since it is spreading quite quickly all over the world.

2. one cannot take comfort from the fact that some countries are still reporting very low case numbers, as this is often merely the result of a lack of testing. Particularly in the US testing has so far not been undertaken on the scale this situation demands (as reported by Mish here, actions taken by the CDC and FDA seem to have led to a delay in the availability of testing kits).

3. the biggest known problems with the virus are:

A) it is highly transmissible and peoplecan transmit the infection even while they are still

B) the incubation period generally ranges from 2 to 14 days, but in outlier cases it can last up to 27 days. This fosters the spread of the infection and suggests lengthy quarantines will be necessary for people suspected of being infected.

C) existing tests are not very reliable – false negatives appear to happen quite frequently and quite a few patients who initially tested negative were found to test positive in a second test.

D) worst of all: around 18-20% of the cases are serious enough to require hospitalization and presumably some form of breathing assistance (blood oxygen saturation levels of these severe cases are reportedly in the 60s; unless oxygen is administered this is fatal). Most if not all health care systems in the countries concerned will be overwhelmed.

As an example, England has just 15 beds for treating severe respiratory problems (i.e., for adult extra-corporeal membrane oxygenation) – at most 28 beds can be made available in a pinch. This was recently revealed during question time in the House of Commons. The conclusion from this is that many people will not get the treatment they actually need – medical assistance will have to be rationed (a term we will see popping up more frequently in the future is “triage”). This in turn will tend to push up mortality rates.

4. there are still many unknowns – we believe the most worrisome of these is that a second infection may well trigger a severe immunopathological response and as a result could be far more dangerous than a first round infection. A 2012 paper that discusses a study of SARS vaccines (h/t Chris Martensen of Peak Prosperity) suggests that this problem may well rear its head. Here is a link to the paper: Immunization with SARS Coronavirus Vaccines Leads to Pulmonary Immunopathology on Challenge with the SARS Virus


We quote from the conclusion:


These SARS-CoV vaccines all induced antibody and protection against infection with SARS-CoV. However, challenge of mice given any of the vaccines led to occurrence of Th2-type immunopathology suggesting hypersensitivity to SARS-CoV components was induced. Caution in proceeding to application of a SARS-CoV vaccine in humans is indicated.


(emphasis added)


In a nutshell: once the immune systems of the mice were trained to recognize the SARS virus (a corona-virus closely related to COVID-19), they went haywire when encountering it again – to the extent that fatal complications in the lungs of the test animals were triggered. The vaccines proved effective against SARS, but  the immune system response proved deadly.

If COVID-19 has similar characteristics, developing a safe vaccine may turn out to be quite difficult. Of course we don’t know yet if that is the case, but information on how reinfections develop should be forthcoming fairly soon.

5. final remarks: one should not make the mistake of believing this to be “no worse than the flu”. Apart from the rather obvious fact that China isn’t shutting down completely every time the flu season comes around, here is a list of the main differences: COVID-19 is not like the flu. Also, the eventual mortality rate remains unknown at this stage. Even in a best case scenario it is certain to be far higher than that of the flu, but we are not likely to get a best case scenario. An excellent discussion of mortality rate calculations and forecasts can be found here.


Economic and Financial Impact

The economic impact of the epidemic is going to be temporary, but it is not yet foreseeable just how temporary. What is certain is that if drastic steps are taken to slow down or stop its spread, the impact is going to be severe.

This was just demonstrated in China. Below are charts of China’s most recent PMI releases (both manufacturing and services PMI) – file under “as bad as it ever gets”:


China’s manufacturing PMI fell to 35.7 points, while the services PMI slumped to an even worse 29.6 points. Presumably it would take an asteroid strike to generate even worse readings.


China is a rather important cog in global manufacturing supply chains, so this would have reverberated across the world even if the epidemic had remained confined to China. Alas, one must fear that similar economic disruptions will eventually be seen in numerous industrialized countries.

In the financial markets arena the greatest problems are likely to emerge in credit markets, particularly in corporate credit. According to the BIS, so-called “zombie corporations” represent an estimated 12% of the world’s corporate debt issuers. These companies depend on gullible investors continually refinancing their debts  in order to muddle on – during boom times, that is.

If we were to take a stab at guessing what investors (even otherwise gullible ones) are likely to do if/when half the world releases PMI data similar to those shown above, refinancing the debt of zombies will probably not be at the top of their list of priorities. It seems more likely that most of them will speed-dial “1-800-GETMEOUT”.

And while the stock market provided some relief to punters with its smart rebound on Monday after last week’s merciless shellacking, we caution that this rebound may be a limited affair. This is a richly valued market to put it mildly, and our warning from early February on US stock market sentiment and positioning should not necessarily be dismissed as being only of short term significance.

As a reminder, here is what we said in our conclusion:


“[…] current sentiment and positioning data strongly suggest that a sizable setback may be at hand. This does not depend on Corona virus-related news: in fact, if a short term advance coincides with an improvement in the news backdrop on the epidemic, the market will likely end up in an even more vulnerable position. We believe one should be very cautious in coming days and weeks, refrain from chasing rallies and think about ways to protect existing positions.”


Dow Jones Industrial Average, daily – a rally to a new high in early February, followed by a veritable massacre. It remains to be seen how far the recent rebound will go, but it should be noted that such huge one day rallies are often hallmarks of bear market conditions.


As it happened, the market did resume its advance in the short term (despite the virus-related news backdrop failing to improve) and “an even more vulnerable position” was the result. Many of the positioning extremes we showed went to even more extreme levels in the process – and such rare outliers are often associated with long term market peaks. We plan to post more on this subject shortly.



It seems to us that one would do well to consider the situation to be potentially quite serious and prepare on a personal level for possible supply disruptions and other unpleasantries. We hope of course that things will turn out better than we currently fear, but one can no longer blindly rely on such hopes.

Meanwhile, investors and traders should expect even more market turmoil in the weeks ahead, especially if the economic impact of the epidemic threatens to become more protracted and severe than is currently assumed. Caveat emptor definitely remains the watchword.


Charts by worldometers, Bloomberg, stockcharts




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our header carries ab black flag. This is due to the recent passing of the main author of the Acting Man blog, Heinz Blasnik, under his nom de plume 'Pater Tenebrarum'. We want to thank you for following his blog for meanwhile 11 years and refer you to the 'Acting Man Classics' on the sidebar to get an introduction to his way of seeing economics. In the future, we will keep the blog running with regular uptates from our well known Co-Authors. For that, some financial help would be greatly appreciated. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


4 Responses to “The Corona Virus Epidemic – Going Global”

  • mantrid:

    COVID-19 is not like the flu but it’s not like SARS either. Definitely nothing close to tuberculosis. And yet my country is locked down entirely. Only groceries and pharmacies are open. It’s like 1981 but without tanks and soldiers in the streets.

    It seems the coronavirus solved many many problems of a lot of people:
    – economic naysayers have their crash and recession finally
    – Keynesians have their windows broken
    – money printers have their printers restarted
    – inflationists got another excuse to have cash banned
    – climate alarmists have CO2 emissions plummeted
    – anti-immigration conservatives have borders shut down
    – leftists got another argument to ensure free universal healthcare
    – TVs have their viewership skyrocketed
    – Democrats have Trump compromised himself
    – Easter-European populists have huge Western shopping malls shut down
    – Deep State and its stooges worldwide have frightened plebs under control again

    Since COVID-19, like Swine Flu and others, is here to stay with us, expect draconian measures and rapid erosion of liberty.

  • trojan1:

    Italy has really got the world panicked… has anyone stopped and thought why such a large and aggressive outbreak??

    Consider this… the catholic practice of communion results in most people in the 1 church drinking from a single cup.. one sip, a wipe of the cloth from the priest, another sip…

    Possibly the most perfect transmission method of a virus ever imagined..

    How many Italians repeated this practice for the weeks leading up to the outbreak?? MILLIONS

    Why are there 300,000 expats in Hong Kong and not 1 has the virus.. my friends say they are out drinking 5 nights a week in crowded bars.. no masks, zero precautions.. same in Singapore, Bangkok, etc.. zero expat cases..

    The virus will blow over. The economics of fear probably wont.

  • utopiacowboy:

    We only need to listen to the guidance and wisdom of our Great Leader, Kim Il Trump. He alone knows everything and we will follow him blindly.

  • VB:

    It is likely that the virus has spread much more widely than reported. It is definitely out of control and will become the fifth coronavirus that stays with us and cases epidemics every year. The good news is that, if this is true, the mortality rate is much lower than reported – about 0.6%, instead of 2-3% – and impacts mostly people over 70 who have other complications.

    Remember, practically all deaths caused by the virus are reported – but infections are reported only after testing, which usually happens only if the infected person shows symptoms or it is known that they have been in contact with an infected person. Apparently, many people are either asymptomatic or show only very mild symptoms, which makes them mistake the disease for a regular flu and not seek medical help – while continuing to infect others.

    Two notable exceptions was the limited and confined population of the ship Diamond Princess and the population of South Korea, where testing has been undertaken on a massive scale after the initial spread. In both cases, a very large part of the population was found to be infected. Consequently, the mortality ratio dropped much lower. About 700 of the 1300 passengers of the ship turned out being infected – but only about 6 have died so far. Even if we dismiss this as a fluke, South Korea (7,041 infected, 44 dead as I am writing this) shows a similar mortality ratio of about 0.6%.

    That’s not necessarily a good thing, however. SARS had a much higher mortality ratio – about 10%. But it was much less infectious and was eventually contained. The much higher infection rate of SARS-CoV2 means that many more people will get infected and many more will die, despite the 0.6% mortality rate.

    Also, there seem to be at least 2 different types of the virus already. The S-type seems to be the original one and is less infectious (about 30% of the infections are caused by it) while the L-type is newer and much more aggressive, causing about 70% of the infections.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • Forensic Analysis of Fed Action on Silver Price
      Forensic Analysis of Fed Action on Silver Price The last few days of trading in silver have been a wild ride. On Wednesday morning in New York, six hours before the Fed was to announce its interest rate hike, the price of silver began to drop. It went from around $22.65 to a low of $22.25 before recovering about 20 cents. At 2pm (NY time), the Fed made the announcement. The price had already begun spiking higher for about two minutes.     As an aside,...

Support Acting Man

Austrian Theory and Investment


THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from]


Mish Talk

    Buy Silver Now!
    Buy Gold Now!