India’s Rapid Degradation

This is Part XI of a series of articles (the most recent of which is linked here) in which I have provided regular updates on what started as the demonetization of 86% of India’s currency. The story of demonetization and the ensuing developments were merely a vehicle for me to explore Indian institutions, culture and society.


The Modimobile is making the rounds amid a flower shower. [PT]

Photo credit: PTI Photo


Tribal cultures face an inherent contradiction. They create poison from within to grow more collectivist, controlling and tyrannical — members of the populace looks for nannies, and they readily find sociopaths to exploit that need. Their lack of organizational skills, their inability to engage in economic calculation and their irrationality lead to massive internal stresses and the ultimate devolution of such an unnatural society.

India finds itself in a situation where it is grasping for more totalitarianism to solve the problems that totalitarianism created. The demonetization exercise was an assertion of India’s underlying tribal and collectivist culture.


Demonetization Pain Continues

Cashless ATMs continue to be the new normal in India. In a recent conversation, economist Professor Madhusudan Raj mentioned that as many as 70% of the ATMs in his city are still not operational. The situation in villages and small towns is much worse. Banks are often clogged with people.

Eventually most people who must have cash will get it, but businesses need easy access to large amounts of their own cash without incurring transaction costs. They continue to face horrendous problems, which are translating into closures, retrenchment of staff, and bankruptcies. The tax authorities are getting increasingly rapacious. According to Professor Madhusudan Raj:


“The tax department is busy conducting raids on old widowers, small traders and merchants like chicken-shops, shoe-shops, small restaurants, gas stations etc.; pretty much anyone who deposited more than half a million rupee in banks during the demonetization process. The department is forcing small traders to declare income under Modi’s PMGKY (Prime Minister poverty alleviation) scheme, but leaves big corrupt business tycoons untouched.”


Draconian regulations on the use of cash are increasing. Businesses are in fear of the State. Freedom of speech is rapidly receding, not only because of fear of the government, but also because Indians are becoming increasingly fanatic.

Any new cash continues to find its way to the financially powerful, leaving small businessmen and the informal sector reeling in economic trauma. The normal rhythm of the economy has been destroyed. People continue to delay discretionary purchases. The market continues to be slow.

Businesses are failing and the poorest are finding employment very difficult to come by. Food prices are still much cheaper than normal, as a result of the economic struggles of poor people. Farmers are facing huge financial pressure in turn.

It is a vicious cycle in which people who at first lacked access to their own money because of the demonetization now face a situation in which they simply don’t have any work and hence no cash.


From the Hindu newspaper: Only three out of forty-five ATMs in the IT-hub city of Hyderabad were functioning on 13 March 2017. Businesses are starving for cash.


As is the case with an irrational tribal society, many members of India’s middle class are utterly lacking in empathy for those who are suffering. Slowly but surely, universal principles assert themselves though, and economic harm is flowing toward them. Alas, they still fail to recognize the chain of causality.


The slow poison of demonetization and populist scams schemes at work: US-listed IT-major Cognizant is expected to slash more than 10,000 jobs. It has around 260,000 employees and around 75 percent of its workforce is based in India. The situation of other IT companies in India is similar. A huge wave of young, mostly unskilled, untrained and uneducated people – about 12 million –  join India’s workforce every year, but have little prospects of finding a job.

Photo credit: Cognizant


Without Reason, the Only Stable Institution is a Tribe

It has been 70 years since the British left India. In these years, Indians have systemically destroyed what the British left behind by asserting their tribal, superstitious and irrational culture.

It was believed that the separation of legislature, judiciary and executive which the British had created would stay. What was forgotten was that such institutions had evolved in Europe because of the tool of reason. Indians imported all the fruits of western civilization — technology, music, movies, Kim Kardashian, etc. — but completely failed to adopt the European concept of reason.

Without reason, India had to drift back to its tribalism. Today, Indian institutions are hollow shells of what was bequeathed by Britain. The executive, the judiciary and the legislature are indistinguishable from each other. One would find it almost impossible to come across even an educated Indian able to properly explain the difference between these three branches of government.

As Professor  Madhusudan Raj notes:


“There is a big cold war going on between the Supreme Court and the Modi government, which is trying to take full control of the courts. Modi’s parliament can now dismiss the appointment of Supreme Court judges in the name of ‘national security’.”


When the British left India, virtually all leaders had been selected and nudged into their positions by them. India was a democracy only in name. Children of these leaders and later on their children had political power.

Jawaharlal Nehru was India’s first Prime Minister. Then it was his daughter’s turn, Indira Gandhi. And then it was the turn of her son Rajiv Gandhi. And then Rajiv’s wife, Sonia Gandhi took over (she ruled using a puppet, Manmohan Singh).

The last vestiges of whatever class Indian politics might have had ended along with the end of Sonia Gandhi’s rule three years ago, and the subsequent inauguration of Narendra Modi.  Now raw tribalism is in full force in India.

It is not only India that is affected.  European institutions have failed and mutated into entities catering to underlying tribalism in nearly every country in Africa, the Middle East, South Asia and most of Latin America. The nation state, a European institution, is too unnatural for these societies.

India seemed like an exception to the international media. This is because the smartest people of India moved to the US and Indian lobbies leveraged this fact to make India look good – despite the fact that India’s per capita GDP of $1,718 is worse than that of most well-recognized banana republics.

There has indeed been one good thing about India though: freedom of speech survived among a minority. This happened not because of any inherent goodness, but because India is an extremely diverse place, perhaps the most unnatural country.

The infighting and stresses it generated have failed to given Indians a collective identity. This cirfcumstance allowed a minority to speak its mind. Alas, even that is now coming to an end. Hindu nationalism, a.k.a. Hindutava, is rapidly weaving Indians into a tribal collective.


But the Media and the World Bank are in Awe

The international media and the World Bank, find inspiration in what is happening in India. India has recently released a GDP growth figure of 7%. India’s new identity card scheme, Aadhaar, is believed to be a massive success, so much so that the World Bank is urging the world to copy it.

The Indian stock market has risen nicely over the last few weeks. So has the Indian rupee. Moreover, Narendra Modi’s party has just celebrated massive victories in recently held provincial elections. What is not to like about India?


“The Aadhaar system is the most sophisticated identification program in the world,” says World Bank economist Paul Romer [100 crore = 1 billion] – click to enlarge.


In my last update, I explained why the 7% growth figure is a mere paper figure not reflected by reality on the ground. India’s economy very likely suffered huge negative growth last quarter. An increase in revenues was only experienced by politicians and bureaucrats, who collected larger bribes than ever. The common man no longer has the courage to haggle over bribes these days. He pays whatever he is asked to pay.

Ironically, Modi gave the common man and particularly so-called educated people in India huge hopes, and not unlike people in North Korea, they are increasingly nationalistic and proud.  93% of the population have indeed signed up for the Aadhaar ID. It is not compulsory to have one, but the Indian government has made it impossible not to have one. People who don’t have these cards are simply opening themselves up to getting exploited in new ways.

It is worth visiting banks when so-called pensions — paltry sums of a few dollars — are coming due for the old and infirm. They grovel and sit for hours outside bank branches, consistently humiliated by everyone, from guards to managers. In this electronic age their pension often goes missing. Then they must run from pillar to post to get what they have been promised.

India’s GDP per capita is $1,718, making it poorer than Africa. You can enforce a perfect tax regime or a perfect ID system (neither of which is actually possible) on such a chaotic society, but you have to have productivity to make use of increased taxes and a better ID system. Indians are mostly unskilled, uneducated, and untrained, in short, largely unfit for the modern economy.

Any rational ruler would have focused on creating competence among Indians, without which any hopes connected to increased taxation will fail. Moreover, the situation can easily become a major humanitarian crisis in the coming age of robots.

Many people will lose their ID cards soon — as perhaps more than 80% of Indians do not live in proper housing. They lack safe storage to preserve such cards. Moreover, only about 10% to 15% of the population are “benefiting” (by getting subsidized food, gas, etc.) from the cards. Could it be that most of these beneficiaries are members of the middle class?


Sensex index, daily. If you wonder why stock markets are not considered good yardsticks of economic performance, ponder the IBC General Index in Caracas for a moment, in local currency terms the best performing stock market in the world over the past 15 years. It is actually close to a record high, similar to the Sensex.  Venezuela’s economy is doing so well, that hungry people are hunting for rats in the streets of Caracas. [PT] – click to enlarge.


India’s stock market has gone up nicely over the last quarter. The stock market is not necessarily a yardstick measuring the performance of the economy. In fact, it often goes up when long-term returns from economic activity are expected to fall. The Indian government has forced Indians to move their money from the informal sector to the formal, in order to help their corporate cronies and increase tax collection.

Alas, India’s growth is generated by its informal sector. Modi has seriously harmed this sector through the demonetization exercise. Eventually, the formal sector, which has been sitting comfortably while it was subsidized by the informal sector, will suffer as well. Twelve million people who join the workforce every year face a horrendous future in a country where failing to find a job is routine.  Indian demographics are a massive liability. And crime is increasing.


It Keeps Getting Worse Ever Faster

I would not have written any more updates on the demonetization crisis, for a lot has already been said. But recently Modi’s party won elections in the province of Uttar Pradesh (UP).  UP is the most populous province of India with 200 million inhabitants, and it has historically decided who comes to power in the federal government. It has per capita GDP of $730, fairly close to that of Afghanistan.

Professor Madhusudan Raj asserts that Modi’s BJP won primarily due to the anti-incumbency vote. If anti-incumbency stays in fashion, Modi might be in trouble in two years time when the next federal elections come. What might he do to avoid the inevitable? In caste- and class-ridden, backward and illiterate UP, demagogy is much more important than economic growth plans.


Would you buy a used car from this Yogi brother? Neither would we. [PT]

Photo via


Modi has appointed Yogi Adityanath as the Chief Minister (CM) of UP. Adityanath has “given up worldly affairs” to be a “sanyasi”. What distinguishes Adityanath is his extreme hatred towards Muslims. He has exhorted Hindu men to convert 100 Muslim girls to Hinduism for each Hindu who converts to Islam.

He wants to make India a pure Hindu nation. Several years ago he started a religious association, Hindu Yuva Vahini, an organization mainly playing host to a criminally-minded unemployed rabble.


Yogi Adityanath asks for unity among Hindus and a religious war


Yogi Adityanath suggests killing 100 Muslims for each Hindu killed [a really nice guy – PT]


With the appointment of Yogi Adityanath as the CM of UP, talk about development is off the table. The issue is now how to make India a non-secular, Hindu nation.


Conclusion – Maybe Give that Wall a Chance…

India’s rapid descent continues. It is hard to dispute that India is well on its way to be the next Pakistan. Or perhaps India is already worse in some ways:


As difficult as it may be to believe – Pakistan’s adult citizens are actually wealthier than their Indian brethren – and the gap is widening [PT] – click to enlarge.


One of the largest illegal migrant groups in the US is from India. In this modern era, India’s crisis will not stay limited to India. As is the case with those from other eastern religions and societies, once they arrive, Indians vote to mirror what they left behind in their home country, often unknowingly — as the virus of totalitarianism is deeply ingrained in the culture of irrationality.

A wall might not be the answer, but Trump isn’t all that wrong.


Another Modimobile  – #MIGA? [PT]

Photo credit: Kevin Frayer / Getty Images


Charts by: StockCharts, Bloomberg


Chart captions and image captions by PT where indicated


Jayant Bhandari grew up in India. He advises institutional investors on investing in the junior mining industry. He writes on political, economic and cultural issues for several publications. He is a contributing editor of the Liberty magazine. He runs a yearly seminar in Vancouver titled Capitalism & Morality.




Emigrate While You Can... Learn More




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


10 Responses to “India: The next Pakistan?”

  • SavvyGuy:

    The entire series of articles written by this author seem to be rather biased, one-sided and unbalanced…”literary diarrhea” IMHO.

    Nowhere did he even once mention that India is the only country in the world to have successfully placed a spacecraft around Mars on its very first attempt a couple of years ago. Or that India recently launched a record number of 104 satellites in a single payload.

    The author is correct in warning that the admixture of religion and politics is highly combustible. However, a more balanced viewpoint would lend some credibility to this author.

  • NoBullshit:

    Very, very bad article. I get his point, about being angry about demonitisation, but I don’t think he relatively cares abou the ‘per capita’ income of the average indian living in the ‘informal’ economy, as he so suggests. He’s probably not been to Pakistan anyways — so he’s not an expert. But, he IS an asshole for saying the following, no matter if he has 100 degrees from harvard, or whichever industry he ‘advises’ in (he’s probably even madder now that it ostensibly costs more to bribe, an ever increasing government officials). ..

    “One of the largest illegal migrant groups in the US is from India. In this modern era, India’s crisis will not stay limited to India. As is the case with those from other eastern religions and societies, once they arrive, Indians vote to mirror what they left behind in their home country, often unknowingly — as the virus of totalitarianism is deeply ingrained in the culture of irrationality. A wall might not be the answer, but Trump isn’t all that wrong.”

    W-T-F. So he hates Modi, but likes Trump. WOW. What rock did this guy crawl out from under?

    And, talk about painting an entire immigrant group black. Might as well call all Muslims terrorists, all Chinese counterfeiters and copycat artists, all Asian kids video game and cell phone addicts, and, well you get the picture. Yes, Satya Nadella and Mr. Pichai are hard at work to figure out how to bribe the World Bank and European governments on privacy laws (because, he believes they, being indian and all, brought over their ‘totalitarian’ aspirations and bribing mentality).

    Writer is in love with the British imperialist and colonial “vestiges” of “rationalism” and is nostalgic of the whites ruling india (implied), or rather, the system the Brits put in, not exactly staying in the hands of the nepotistic Gandhis. WTF. let me repeat. WTF x 10. He should know that the Greeks gave birth to democracy, and the Brits, nor any western democracy have any ownership nor form to emulate (Brits started democracy somewhere in the 16th/17th century, so they’re relatively new entrants anyways).

    Writer erases 3,000 years of systems of education which existed and casts it all as “tribalism.” What an idiot. Did he know before the idea of a nation state even existed, most foreigners wanted to come to South Asia to conquer and invade it? to trade with it? He should read about this racist fucker named Macauley, who hated india’s cultural vibrancy so much, that he wrote countless letters on how to destroy it (to make indians be indian only in ‘blood and color’ but British in every other way), so that so that England can maintain it’s grasp on power on india.

    IF HE COULD, WRITER WOULD PAINT HIS SKIN WHITE, convert to Christianity, and put on a fake aristrocratic English accent. Or perhaps he has. BTW someone should tell him his blog has several grammatical errors, for all his love of English culture/reason/society.


    • sufganiyah:


      The truth isn’t always pretty and it never cares about your feelings.

      • NoBullshit:

        Holy fuck! If this author speaks the “truth,” would love to see him lie! Must be better than going to the movies.

        Thus, not sure what you mean by “truth” not caring about feelings. Who cares about feelings. Fuck that. This author doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Here’s your “truth-iness”:

        Author advises the mining industry. He’s almost always in “spin” mode. His clients can no longer easily bribe government officials for mining licenses, lest they wire monies to Mauritius, Costa Rica, Guadeloupe, or some other far off bastion where cronies like Sharad Pawar have their monies (Swiss and Euro channels now being closed, along with demonitization closing avenues for corruption).

        Author connects demonitization as a precursor and harbinger to all the “ills” of Indian society, of all that is wrong with Indian people, its diaspora, and indeed its heritage “tribalism” which are all sort of inexorable causes of the current political edicts being doled out by the likes of successive governments. As if to say, South Asians, no matter their religion, creed, caste, etc., because they’re primitive tribals, needed to be TAMED like circus animals, by the superior, white colonialists. If only the author could hear his own article being read back to him.

        Author would do much, much better to take a lesson in economic history, to understand the trade deficit of india, its current accoutn deficit, its need of FDI, excruciating need of imports, burgeoning labor force, all of which would be ameliorated with more liberal economic reforms, rather than letting the informal or “black” economy continue to subsist on government handouts and a cash and barter system. Under the authors implied suggestion of repealing demonetization, India would look more like Venezuela, where there’s currently 2600% like inflation, more than 26 constitution changes, currently waiting for UN handouts for food and medicine.

        • sufganiyah:

          You’re taking the article way too personally. It obviously hit a nerve and brought up some deeply ingrained issues…

        • martelhabermann:

          nobullshit>> His clients can no longer easily bribe government officials for mining licenses,

          This is an ad-hominem attack, a response that casts aspersions about the author’s character instead of responding to the content of his article.

          To an outside observer it would appear that corruption in Indian political funding has been given a major boost, with the 2017 Indian finance bill removing the constraints and reporting requirements around political donations by corporations.

          Going forward, Indian corporates can donate any amount to political parties without needing to disclose these donations (earlier, donations had been capped at 7.5% of the average net profit over 3 years, and the names of the recipients had to be disclosed annually). India’s political parties also appear to have been freed of the obligation to report who their donors are. An “electoral bond” scheme (a bearer bond) for political donations has also been proposed, which would allow political parties to receive donations through the banking system without a link being established between them and their donors.

          It is also interesting to note that these changes to the rules were brought in at the last minute, bypassing their regular parliamentary process. This supports Bhandari’s assertion that the institutions of the country have broken down.

    • martelhabermann:

      >> He should read about this racist fucker named Macauley, who hated india’s cultural vibrancy so much,

      First, it may be worth considering how to spell the name correctly: it is M-a-c-a-u-l-a-y.

      >> that he wrote countless letters on how to destroy it (to make indians be indian only in ‘blood and color’
      >> but British in every other way)

      You might want to consider reading what he actually wrote (hint: it is on the web).

      Macaulay had been horrified by the abject conditions he saw around him in India. At that time, educational opportunities were out of the reach of the vast majority of Indians, both due to abject poverty and due to the Indian caste system which forbade the lower castes from improving themselves.

      Macaulay’s response was to campaign for, and to set up a universally accessible education system for people in British controlled territories. Macaulay did not have a high opinion of the rote-based education system in vogue in India at that time; instead, he pushed for education that was grounded in rationality and scientific thinking. In a major break from the practices of the time, education was to be made accessible to all, irrespective of birth.

      Macaulay also did not wish to impose his culture upon Indians; he instead proposed that the first Indians educated in his proposed system be tasked with adapting it to suit their culture and values.

      Macaulay had also predicted that as a result of his proposed education system, Britain’s Indian subjects would eventually demand european institutions for themselves, including self-determination and freedom. He had welcomed this, saying “whenever it comes, it will be the proudest day in English history.”

      Macaulay’s writings are readily accessible on the web. The inability to read and comprehend these would be a sign of the irrationality that Bhandari writes about.

  • prark:

    >> once they arrive, Indians vote to mirror what they left behind in their home country

    The linked articles refer to actions Pakistani immigrant actions. Do you have the link for the one with the Indians?

    • nobsplease:

      indian immigrants are one of the most highly educated, and are probably in top 5% wage earners in USA. And this author (who is one), just blanket states as if they are like bottom 50% of India (in terms of herd mentality).

      In fact, this whole article suffers from the same prejudice. Yes, there are ATMs without cash , but those are like may be 1% (not even double digit % !!) , and this author makes it sound it the whole system is coming unglued.

      This is the problem with investment advisors in general, they are either sheep or the other extreme (like this author)…they cant be prudent, smart, balanced… If they were, there is LOT of money to be made in finance/investments and they would have been so rich they that wouldn’t bother(better things to do) writing garbage blanket prejudiced and biased articles.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • In The Long Run We Are All Alive
      Prophet of Doom In 1976, economist Herbert Stein, father of Ben Stein, the economics professor in Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, observed that U.S. government debt was on an unsustainable trajectory.  He, thus, established Stein’s Law:   “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”   Herbert Stein, looking worried about the budget deficit. [PT]   Stein may have been right in theory.  Yet the unsustainable trend of U.S. government debt outlasted...

Support Acting Man

Austrian Theory and Investment


The Review Insider


Dog Blow

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from]


Mish Talk

    Buy Silver Now!
    Buy Gold Now!