Business under Pressure

A recent post by Mish points to the fact that many of the business-related data that have been released in recent months continue to point to growing weakness in many parts of the business sector. We show a few charts illustrating the situation below:

 

1-Total Business SalesA long term chart of total business sales. The recent decline seems congruent with a recession, but many other indicators are not yet confirming a recession – click to enlarge.

 

2-Wholesalers - inventories to salesWholesale inventories to sales ratio – ever since the widespread adoption of just-in-time inventory management, such a high level in the I/S ratio indicates a weakening economy – click to enlarge.

 

3-gdpnow-forecast-evolutionThe Atlanta Fed’s GDP Now model shows that economists were once again too optimistic about Q1 growth.

 

Lastly, here is a chart recently presented by Albert Edwards of SocGen, which shows domestic economy-wide non-financial earnings growth in the US. Edwards argues that investment spending tends to follow profit growth, which intuitively makes sense (we offer an alternative explanation for this relationship below). He therefore expects the recent downturn in GAAP earnings to be followed by cutbacks in capital expenditures:

 

4-whole economy profitsUS non-financial economy-wide profits have begun to decline to the “recession threshold” – investment tends to follow with a lag – click to enlarge.

 

A long term chart of the annual growth rate in industrial production shows that the extent of the recent decline has usually not been seen outside of recessions either. Very small and short-lived dips into slightly negative territory occasionally turn out to be meaningless, but not declines of the size recently witnessed. While the chart below begins only in the late 1960s, we have ascertained that this actually holds true for the entire post WW2 era.

 

5-Industrial Production, long termIndustrial production index and y/y growth rate, long term – click to enlarge.

 

Conventionally a lot of blame for the recent weakness is attributed to weak oil prices and the stronger dollar. These factors have certainly exerted some influence. For instance, shale oil production has been a large contributor to investment and employment growth at the margin. Meanwhile, total goods exports have declined noticeably as well.

On the other hand, the decline in energy prices lowers input costs for a great many industries and is also a tailwind for consumers. Moreover, the impact of exchange rates on trade is probably smaller than is widely held. If one looks e.g. at Germany’s trade data during strong and weak euro periods in recent years, little of the expected correlation is evident and the same hold for Japan’s trade data (in Japan, the opposite of what was expected has happened).

Weakness in US exports has probably more to do with weakness in economic growth overseas than with the dollar’s exchange rate. We are therefore going to look at the problem from a different perspective.

 

A Distorted Capital Structure

The industrial production index shown above is chain-weighted Fisher index that measures the estimated real value added by the combined output of manufacturing, mining and utilities. All such indexes suffer from the usual problems one encounters with aggregation, but by comparing various sub-indexes, one can get a rough idea of which stages of the economy’s production structure are attracting the largest share of investment.

As one would expect, whenever interest rates decline and the money supply and credit expand, economic activity shifts to the higher stages of the capital structure, i.e., capital goods production, mining, real estate – everything that is temporally distant from the final goods stage. This is not problematic when real savings have actually increased and interest rates decline on account of lower time preferences. However, it becomes a problem when interest rates are artificially lowered in the course of credit expansion from thin air.

Below we show the ratio of capital vs. consumer goods production. Typically this ratio will rise during boom periods and decline during busts.

 

6-Capital vs consumer goods productionThe ratio of capital goods (business equipment) vs. consumer goods production. Normally, the ratio peaks at the end of a boom and quickly contracts in the subsequent correction. The beginning correction in 2012 was however arrested early by additional monetary pumping in the form of QE3. As a result there has been an unusually long period of sideways movement at an elevated level – click to enlarge.

 

Looking at the sub-indexes themselves, one can also see that following the 2008 crisis, capital and consumer goods production have drifted apart in an unusual way. Consumer goods production has only recovered very reluctantly, resp. not at all in the case of non-durables. The next chart shows the production indexes for capital goods, durable and non-durable consumer goods since the early 1980s:

 

7-Industrial production dehomogenizedCapital goods production (black line), durable consumer goods (purple line) and non-durable consumer goods production (red line) – click to enlarge.

 

If one thinks about the nature of real savings, they consist of final goods that have been produced but not consumed, and can therefore be employed to sustain those working in longer term projects. If a sufficient amount of real savings is available, the production structure can be lengthened, thereby becoming more productive in the long term.

This requires however that market interest rates are left to their own devices – if they are not, too much will be invested in the wrong lines (as a rule, interest rates are manipulated downward, resulting in too many factors of production being attracted to the higher stages). Since there is a continual stream of consumer goods emerging, it takes a while for businessmen to notice that there is an imbalance, that relative prices have been falsified and that capital consumption has “paid” for the consumption that has taken place. Many usually notice when it is too late (such as those active in the commodity industries over the past two years, who have seen their accounting profits from the boom period disappear rather quickly).

Both the amount of available savings as well as future demand are overestimated during the boom. Now inventories are however rising, with the bulk of the build-up occurring in raw and intermediate goods, for which downstream demand is lower than expected. The less specific those are, the easier it is to sell them, but not at the prices they once commanded.

Next we take a look at retail sales. As can be seen, retail sales have increased far above their pre-crisis peak in recent years, even though consumer goods production has been neglected.

 

8-Retail salesRetail sales since 2001 – click to enlarge.

 

In short, the balance between saving and consumption was actually not really supportive of the relative increase in capital goods production. Time preferences were higher than the Fed-manipulated market interest rate backdrop would suggest. Of course the US economy is not a closed economy, so to some degree this also reflects a shift of lower order goods production to other countries, from whence they can be imported, while foreign savings are partly invested in the US.

We can nevertheless be quite certain that the current configuration of the capital structure is not sustainable (in certain sectors of the economy this is increasingly visible already). Given that consumption was underestimated and savings were overestimated, not all of the long-term projects that were initiated on account of low interest rates can possibly be sustained. The recent flattening in retail sales may actually indicate that the process has reached its inevitable end (i.e., that we are entering the forced saving phase of the boom, since more and more final goods have so to speak become tied up relative to those that are released).

Given the large stock of capital that has already been accumulated in the past and the fact that even during booms, more real wealth tends to be produced than is consumed in most cases, monetary pumping can delay the onset of a bust considerably. While there is no more “QE” in the US, money supply growth remains at a historically high level. Broad true money supply growth has re-accelerated to around 8% year-on-year as of March.

 

9-TMS-2-growth rateMoney supply TMS-2, y/y growth rate – click to enlarge.

 

The main impetus for money supply growth continues to come from commercial and industrial lending, which is still the fastest growing type of bank credit.

 

10-C&I LoansThe y/y growth rate of commercial and industrial lending stood at 11.23% as of early April – click to enlarge.

 

Interestingly, this is happening in spite of the combined value of charge-offs and delinquencies in C&I loans rising at a 52% annualized rate as of Q4 2015, the fastest pace since early 2008, and above the peak growth levels observed in 2001.

We suspect that quite a bit of this credit growth has fueled financial engineering in the form of share buybacks, M&A activity and even dividend financing. This is helping to keep asset prices elevated for the time being. Small businesses are however no longer very enthusiastic – the NFIB small business optimism indicator has peaked with the end of QE3, along with the oil price:

 

11-NFIB-optimismAfter recovering to a lower high relative to the previous boom, small business confidence has entered a downtrend – click to enlarge.

 

Lastly, here is a long term chart of the capital goods to consumer goods production ratio. This reflects partly the shift in global production mentioned above, but mainly the massive credit expansion that has been set into motion since the gold exchange standard was abandoned with Nixon’s 1971 default.

Prior to the beginning of this credit expansion, the ratio moved in a broad sideways channel – ever since, it has trended upward. The chart also shows that extended periods of the ratio remaining at a high level after reaching a peak are fairly rare.

 

12-Capital vs consumer goods prod LTRatio of capital vs. consumer goods production, long term – reflecting an extended credit boom as well as the expansion in international trade and investment, with the US economy attracting a lot of foreign investment. The credit boom is the problem – and it is a global phenomenon as well – click to enlarge.

 

Conclusion

The economy’s capital structure remains imbalanced as a result of the enormous amount of monetary pumping since 2008 (total TMS-2 growth since then: approx. 128%). There is a limit to this though, even if it cannot be quantified. What can be stated though is that the greater the boom, the greater the eventual bust usually is. There are now more and more indications that a decisive inflection point may be quite near.

 

Charts by: St. Louis Federal Reserve Research, Atlanta Federal Reserve, SocGen, SentimenTrader

 

 

 

Emigrate While You Can... Learn More

 


 

 
 

Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.

   

Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA

   
 

One Response to “US Economy – Ongoing Distortions”

  • vfor:

    This post is a gem, superb analysis! Amazingly how well the current state fit with predictions by the Austrian framework as outlined in Human Action and Man Economy and State.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • Pushing Past the Breaking Point
      Schemes and Shams Man’s willful determination to resist the natural order are in vain.  Still, he pushes onward, always grasping for the big breakthrough. The allure of something for nothing is too enticing to pass up.   From the “displays of disbelief, revealing touching old-fashioned notions” file... [PT]   Systems of elaborate folly have been erected with the most impossible of promises.  That prosperity can be attained without labor.  That benefits...
  • The Myth of Capitalism - A Book by Jonathan Tepper
      Crony Capitalism vs. Free Markets Many of our readers are probably aware of the excellent work our friend Jonathan Tepper does for Variant Perception (VP)*****, a financial research boutique that really does bring a unique perspective to the table*. Jonathan (with co-author Denise Hearn) has just added a new book to his résumé, which is going to be released on 12 November: The Myth of Capitalism (MoC) – Monopolies and the Death of Competition** (a link to the official site is at the...
  • Three Cheers for James Riley!
      Going All In All people, of both good and questionable character, share a singular talent.  They excel at taking something that’s tolerable in moderation, and then pushing it to the outer limits of absurdity.  Why live with restraint when you can get radical?   A fairly famous stretch of LA riverbed graffiti... [PT] Photo credit: saber   Public and private debt levels, NASDAQ stock valuations, the federal register, face tattoos, canned energy drinks.  You name...
  • Crumbling Piles of Sand
      Just a Little Avalanche or an Implosion? A few years ago, we briefly discussed the dynamics of sand piles in these pages, which are a special field of study in mathematics and physics (mathematically inclined readers can take a look at two papers on the subject here:”Driving Sandpiles to Criticality and Beyond “ (PDF) and  'Games on Line Graphs and Sand Piles “(PDF) – unfortunately two other studies that used to be available have in the meantime disappeared from the...
  • When Fake Money Becomes Scarce
      Remaining Focused A rousing display of diversions this week assured the American populace was looking every which way but right under its collective nose.  Midterm elections.  White House spats with purveyors of fake news.  The forced resignation of Attorney General Sessions...   Old drug warrior (otherwise recused) on his way home to Alabama...   Sideshows like these, and many more, offered near limitless opportunities to focus on matters of insignificance.  Why...
  • Fun and Profit - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      While Not Saving The Planet, Let Us At Least Have A Good Time The price of gold went up seven bucks, and that of silver rose eight pennies. For many people, the attraction to gold and silver began with a desire to protect themselves from the monetary train wreck of 2008. That often grew into a sense that gold is the solution to that problem.   The post 2008 GFC monetary train wreck: US true broad money supply is expanded by more than 153% in a mere decade, as the Fed takes...
  • Wizard’s First Rule – Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      The Last to Go Terry Goodkind wrote an epic fantasy series. The first book in the series is entitled Wizard’s First Rule. We recommend the book highly, if you’re into that sort of thing.   An image from the title page of Terry Goodkind's best-selling fantasy epic “Wizard's First Rule”. We'd be at bit wary of standing around on that stone-slab bridge to be honest. [PT]   However, for purposes of this essay, the important part is the rule...
  • US Stock Market - Re-Coupling with a Panic Cycle?
      The Mighty Gartman Investment newsletter writer Dennis Gartman (a.k.a. “the Commodities King”) has been a target of ridicule at Zerohedge for a long time. His pompous style of writing and his uncanny ability to frequently make perfectly mistimed short term market calls have made him an easy target.* It would be quite ironic if a so far quite good recommendation he made last week were to turn into the call of a lifetime (see ZH: “Gartman: 'We Are Officially Recommending Shorting...
  • Roger Barris for Congress!
      Economic Man Threatens to Leave You Alone if Elected This one is mainly for readers residing in that glorious water source for California commonly known as Colorado. In case you are not aware of it yet, Roger “Economic Man” Barris, an occasional contributor to this site, is running for Congress in Colorado on a Libertarian Party ticket. We will briefly explain why you should vote for Roger, but first two pictures:   Roger Barris, Libertarian Party candidate for the House...
  • It's Not That Day Just Yet - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Degrees of Urgency Monday was Veterans Day, a bank holiday in the US. The prices of gold and silver dropped $23 and $0.61 respectively. “But isn’t gold supposed to go up when...?”   Warren Buffet and Aragorn discuss what to do with the gold. Aragorn wants it, because he knows that even if it's not today, “that day” will come. [PT]   Why? Because everyone else will bid it up. Why? Because they expect someone else to bid it up. Why? Warren Buffet is...
  • Revisiting the Halloween Effect
      From Crash Danger to End-of-the-Year Ramp   [Ed note by PT: we are unfortunately a week late in posting this issue of SI, which didn't reach us in time due to a technical problem. We decided to post it belatedly anyway: for one thing, the effect under discussion is normally in effect until the end of the year; for another, the statistical validity of this information goes beyond the current year, as it is a recurring phenomenon. Lastly we would note that we have a strong...

Support Acting Man

Item Guides

Austrian Theory and Investment

j9TJzzN

The Review Insider

Archive

Dog Blow

350x200

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

Mish Talk

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!