Disappearing Growth

FRANKFURT, Germany – Nothing much to report from the stock market yesterday. Investors are regaining their calm. A few weeks ago, it looked as though the end of the world had begun. We are talking, of course, about the world in which credit, stocks, and central bank reputations only go up.


Eccles BuildingFated to eventually become a house of ill repute: the Mariner Eccles building (Fed board HQ)

Photo credit: AgnosticPreachersKid


But after a big fright in August, investors recovered their relaxed madness. They concluded that there was nothing to worry about. They may be right. You never know. But our guess is that the end of the world has already begun… and they just can’t face it.


1-SPXThe SPX, monthly – a proxy for the seemingly never-ending asset bubble. What if the end of the party is already here and people have just not noticed yet? – click to enlarge.


Since the end of World War II, credit has been expanding in the U.S. At first, it was a healthy expansion. Young, middle-class families took out mortgages and ran up bills on “charge cards,” such as Diners Club and American Express.

Then, in the late 1950s, came the first credit cards. This was accompanied by large increases in consumer credit. Until the 1970s, all was well, because wages were rising, too. And with so much new technology coming online, people believed their wages could only increase.

Debt was no problem – neither for the nation nor for households. We would “grow our way out of it.” But a strange – and as yet not fully understood – new trend began in the 1970s. After accounting for inflation, incomes for most Americans dramatically tapered off.


2-debt, debt and GDPTotal credit market debt, federal debt and GDP – a non-problem on its way to becoming an intractable problem … – click to enlarge.


The economy was slowing, too, after taking the effects of inflation into account. At first, this was thought to be temporary – a fluke, perhaps caused by the 1973 oil crisis. But the trend toward lower economic growth continued. Decade after decade, the trend in GDP growth was down. In most parts of the U.S., GDP per person peaked in the 1970s or 1980s.

Remarkably, the average American working man earns less today than he did a half century ago (again, accounting for changes in consumer price inflation). That is not the same as saying that a person with a good job earns less today than he did in the 1960s.

According to Census Bureau figures, the average inflation-adjusted wage for Americans in the top 5% of earners is up by more than 75% since 1967. Women earn a lot more, too.

But good jobs have become scarce. The labor participation rates – the number of people who have jobs or are looking for jobs as a percentage of the people who are of working age – is at its lowest level since 1977.


3-Labor force participation rateLabor force participation rate – at its lowest level since 1977. Something is clearly amiss – click to enlarge.

Debt Goes Sour

But although economic growth and most people’s incomes slipped, debt (the flip side of credit) kept growing. This was Stage II – the unhealthy phase of the credit expansion. No longer backed by broad-based wage increases, debt was expanding beyond the capacity of the economy – and borrowers – to repay it.

Now we were asking for trouble. You may be wondering how this was possible. Why would lenders extend credit to people who couldn’t pay back? The answer: The fix was in.

In 1971, President Nixon dramatically transformed the global monetary system. Under the previous Bretton Woods system, the dollar was backed by gold. And the major global currencies traded at fixed rates to the dollar… and by extension to gold.

This meant a nation couldn’t get too far into debt… especially when it came to its trading partners. Trade surplus nations – which amassed dollars in return for net exports to the U.S. – could ask to redeem their dollars in gold. This caused gold to leave the overspending nation and flow to the creditor nation.

That’s how the U.S. got so much gold in the first place. France and Britain spent more than they could afford on World War I. The U.S. sold them food, weapons, and fuel… and demanded gold in repayment. But by the 1960s, the shoe was on the other foot.

The U.S. started spending money on both “guns and butter” – a Great Society at home and a war in Vietnam. Much of the spending to fund the war in Vietnam ended up as dollars in the hands of Vietnamese branches of French banks.


French president de Gaulle warns of the dollar-centric monetary system that was leading to enormous debt growth and would one day lead to an uncontrollable crisis. He started coming for his gold shortly thereafter, ultimately exposing the fact that dollars were no longer fully backed by gold.


And when, in 1965, president Charles de Gaulle sent the French navy across the Atlantic to pick up $150 million worth of gold in exchange for dollars, it was greeted like a long-lost relative at the reading of the will.

Finally, with gold being airlifted from Fort Knox to meet foreign demands for payment, rather than honor Washington’s promise to convert dollars to gold, Nixon panicked and defaulted. Henceforth, anyone holding dollars was on his own …


Nixon announces that the US will default on the gold exchange standard by “temporarily” suspending gold convertibility, while raising tariffs concurrently. Essentially he was telling a whole bunch of lies in the process, while proudly parading his appalling economic ignorance. This was called the “Nixon shock”. We’re not sure if people were more shocked about the lies or the ignorance, but surely many people must have wondered if it was April 1 instead of early August.


“Tall Paul” Takes Over

It all would have gone bad very fast. By April 1980, the annual rate of consumer price inflation was running at almost 15%. Gold soared as high as $800 an ounce. It looked as though Nixon’s new fiat money system would go off the rails soon – as all previous experiments with paper money had.

Instead, in 1979, President Carter appointed Paul Volcker as Fed chairman. Volcker stepped in front of the runaway train and commanded it to halt. And it did. By January 1981, “Tall Paul” jacked up the federal funds rate – the key lending rate in the economy – not to 2%… or 4%… or even 8%. He set it at 19% – and placed the train squarely on the tracks again.

We remember the howls of discontent. Volcker was “stifling the economy,” said the politicians. He was “killing jobs,” said the newspapers. He was causing “the worst downturn since the Great Depression,” said the economists. But Volcker didn’t budge. And when Ronald Reagan entered the White House in 1981, he backed Volcker.


volckerPaul Volcker applied tough medicine for about two years, but by the time he became Fed chairman, US true money supply growth had already been declining sharply for two years running. In other words, the main driver of price inflation was already in retreat when he entered the scene. Later, in 1982, he produced the biggest one year surge in the broad money supply aggregate TMS-2 that had been seen since the war, a feat never again repeated. While he fended off assorted yammering politicians in the first two years of his chairmanship, it is a good bet this was actually a mock battle to pull the wool over the eyes of the hoi-polloi. We won’t be able to shake his firmly cemented reputation as an “inflation fighter”, but it is not nearly as deserved as is commonly assumed. Plus, as Bill Bonner notes below, in the best case he saved a system simply not worth saving.

Photo credit: John Duricka / AP


Volcker announced his intention to squeeze inflation out of the system soon after he became Fed chairman. Bonds – which do well when inflation is low – should have rallied. Investors should have raced to lock in roughly 10% yield available on the 10-year Treasury note. Instead, bonds price fell… and bond yields rose.

Then, as now, people were not aware – or were not willing to believe – that a major change had occurred. It wasn’t until 1982 that the bond market turned; finally, investors realized that it was a new world. Volcker saved the system. Bond yields – and interest rates – have been coming down ever since.

Too bad he didn’t save a better system. Not many men can resist the appeal of free money. Americans proved they were no better at it than others. Falling interest rates and the paper dollar gave them a way to impoverish themselves – by spending money they hadn’t earned.

They took the opportunity offered to them. They borrowed and spent… and drove the entire world forward at a furious pace. But now that stage is over.

More to come …


4-TYXThe “stability” of the “scientific monetary policy” in one stark image. Investors only realized in late 1981/early 1982 that the era of rising CPI inflation had ended – a reaction delayed by nearly two years. Something similar could well be happening now – an era is ending, they just don’t know it yet – click to enlarge.


Charts by stockcharts, St. Louis Fed


Image captions by PT


The above article originally appeared at the Diary of a Rogue Economist, written for Bonner & Partners. Bill Bonner founded Agora, Inc in 1978. It has since grown into one of the largest independent newsletter publishing companies in the world. He has also written three New York Times bestselling books, Financial Reckoning Day, Empire of Debt and Mobs, Messiahs and Markets.




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our header carries ab black flag. This is due to the recent passing of the main author of the Acting Man blog, Heinz Blasnik, under his nom de plume 'Pater Tenebrarum'. We want to thank you for following his blog for meanwhile 11 years and refer you to the 'Acting Man Classics' on the sidebar to get an introduction to his way of seeing economics. In the future, we will keep the blog running with regular uptates from our well known Co-Authors. For that, some financial help would be greatly appreciated. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


One Response to “The End of the World Has Already Begun”

  • therooster:

    I can certainly say that the FED’s version of currency (debt) is not the greatest thing to come along in the last 44 years but how about some comments about the dollar’s role as a real-time price measure in support of debt-free trades ? Do we have any comments (or recognition) of that particular application for the dollar ?

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • Forensic Analysis of Fed Action on Silver Price
      Forensic Analysis of Fed Action on Silver Price The last few days of trading in silver have been a wild ride. On Wednesday morning in New York, six hours before the Fed was to announce its interest rate hike, the price of silver began to drop. It went from around $22.65 to a low of $22.25 before recovering about 20 cents. At 2pm (NY time), the Fed made the announcement. The price had already begun spiking higher for about two minutes.     As an aside,...

Support Acting Man

Austrian Theory and Investment


THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]


Mish Talk

    Buy Silver Now!
    Buy Gold Now!