Anne-Elisabeth Moutet on France’s Sclerosis

French “refugee” Anne-Elisabeth Moutet – one of the many French citizens who have fled the economic paralysis of France for the welcoming shores of Albion and made London the sixth-largest French city in the process – has written another very interesting article on the situation in France. She compares the current environment in France to that in Britain in the late 1970s. The main difference is of course that no equivalent to Margaret Thatcher who could pull the cart out of the mud is in sight anywhere. Instead, France has Marine Le Pen waiting in the wings, whose mercantilist, statist economic philosophy is mainly characterized by being just as bad as the socialism of Francois “Welfare State Incarnate” Hollande.

Hollande, who as we previously noted, has nothing to lose anymore given his record low 13% approval rating, has recently replaced the catastrophic crypto-Marxist “economy minister” Arnaud Montebourg with his polar opposite Emmanuel Macron (for details on this, see: “Reform in France – Mission Impossible?”). The latter apparently at least appears to know a thing or two about the laws of economics. He is also not afraid to voice uncomfortable truths in this context, to the chagrin of France’s left, which is howling with righteous indignation. As Ms. Moutet writes:


“France’s new economy minister, 36-year-old Emmanuel Macron, who has been tasked with tackling long-delayed reforms to reverse the country’s decline, is having a hard time. Every statement of his, it seems, provokes a storm of abuse from the politicians to the public.

Mr Macron, a former investment banker who was given his cabinet job less than two months ago, almost immediately suggested that the 35-hour working week – introduced by the Socialist government in 2000 with the aim of reducing unemployment by “sharing” the available work – could be done away with. He was roundly insulted.

Shortly afterward, he mentioned that 20 per cent of a Breton pork abattoir workforce, laid off because of a plant closure, would find it difficult to get new jobs because they were illiterate and couldn’t, for instance, pass a driver’s license exam, barring them from a number of available jobs. The reactions were so venomous that he was nearly punched in the face on the floor of the House by an MP from his own party, Olivier Dussopt. “You’ve grievously insulted my mother! She’s a laborer, she’s got no degree, she’s been laid off twice already!” Mr Macron had to issue a lengthy public apology.

Mr Macron favors workfare over the current long-term benefits handed out to France’s 3.5 million unemployed and suggested in a recent interview that recipients had “duties” as well as “rights”. Cue more outrage, with L’Humanité, the Communist daily, howling that he was hand in hand with the employers’ federation to “guilt” the jobless.

Mr Macron seems to specialize in straight-talking: in identifying core problems of the French economy and naming them. This is making him one of the most unpopular people in France, because saying blunt truths is seen here as an unforgivable act of aggression.

“The banker Macron? We don’t know him, he’s never said or done anything that was remotely of the Left,” the maverick Socialist defector, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, said in a radio interview. “He’s not one of us,” a columnist in the left-leaning Le Nouvel Observateur thundered. “He’s not just from any bank: he’s from Rothschild’s.”


(emphasis added)

Truth telling certainly seems impolitic in France, but the indignant political left has of course absolutely nothing to offer by way of viable alternatives. After all, its policies have been tried over and over again in France, to disastrous results every time.


emmanuel-macronNew French economy minister Emmanuel Macron: France’s political left is up in arms over the minister’s so far timid attempts to reform the economy that has been run into the ground by socialist policies.

(Photo via


France’s Brezhnevnian Political Elite

As Ms. Moutet notes, French workers are riven by deep anxieties. The surprisingly small number of people actually working in the private sector are scared of losing their jobs, because they know they won’t get anything better. Meanwhile, government State employees, who are essentially are in no danger whatsoever of getting fired, are striking at every opportunity. It seems increasingly likely that even the most basic infrastructure will eventually cease to work. Writes Ms. Moutet:


“The vast majority of the French not directly employed by the state (about one quarter of the workforce) live in a state of pervasive fear of unemployment that is probably impossible to overstate.

One quarter of the under-25s are unemployed; while employers also actively discriminate against over-50s. France is depressed and gloomy. More and more, my native country reminds me of the Britain I knew from my days at school during the Winter of Discontent, those grey and pessimistic times when the joke was that the last person leaving England should remember to turn out the lights. We don’t have power cuts yet, but we have more and more power outages. The French, especially in the public sector, go on strike on the flimsiest of pretexts. Moreover, the country is riven by class envy and doubts most of its public figures.


(emphasis added)


france-youth-unemployment-rateFrance’s youth unemployment rate is testament to the enormous institutional unemployment so-called “pro-labor” regulation has produced in Europe’s welfare states. Among the major economies, France and Italy are the worst offenders in this respect. It is no wonder France’s youth is disillusioned, apathetic and increasingly prone to radicalization, as the surprisingly large number of French youth joining the jihad of ISIS attests to – click to enlarge..


France’s political elite meanwhile has proved quite adept at tapping into this discontent on occasion of Mr. Hollande’s election, but seems otherwise tone-deaf. The attitude seems to be that it is not the political elites that might be at fault. Instead, the voting sheep just don’t know what’s good for them:


“Like Mr Macron, François Hollande is a graduate of the École Nationale d’Administration (ENA), the incestuous, elite civil service school that shapes most French political and economic leaders. Mr Hollande consciously decided to forget economic realism and pandered to the national psychosis to get elected in 2012. “My enemy is finance!” he thundered. He promised more civil service jobs, that he would reverse most of Nicolas Sarkozy’s timid reforms and cuts, and insisted that he “didn’t like the rich”. Embracing their inner sans-culotte (the Left-wing partisans of the French Revolution), French voters seized his cue enthusiastically.

But, soon enough, it became obvious that Mr Hollande was part and parcel of the same comfortable insider crowd that has been entrusted with power in France for decades. Not only was he an énarque – the name given to a graduate of the ENA – who only hired other énarques; he even narrowed it down to giving three dozen top jobs to the friends he had made in his very own ENA class, between 1978 and 1980.

The Brezhnevian intricacies of the tight circles of power in France are imperfectly understood by the population at large, but there’s a certain tone, a way of telling the public that you know what they want better than they do, to which the French have increasingly grown allergic.


(emphasis added)

The problem is that this attitude is driving French voters in droves into the arms of Ms. Le Pen’s Front National. Sociologist Christophe Guilluy has analyzed this phenomenon with the result that the elites are ignoring and ridiculing his findings, because they are not in line with their view of how society “should” behave. As Ms. Moutet notes in this context:


“Marine Le Pen has tapped into this seething discontent: she now draws as many votes from the disenfranchised Left as from the discontented Right.

This national dismay has been analysed for almost a decade by the young sociologist Christophe Guilluy, now 40, in a series of essays that it has been fashionable to decry in academic and political circles. Mirroring the popular refusal to acknowledge economic reality and accept reform, the elites have dismissed Guilluy’s findings because they don’t tally with their idealized view of how society should behave.”


(emphasis added)

Mr. Guilluy points out that a kind of modern-day feudalism has developed in France, with the average citizen no longer able to afford to live in the areas where the elites have their residences. As a result, many people have moved out of large cities to the countryside, where living costs are much lower, but job opportunities are even scarcer. These are the people who simply don’t want to live in the banlieus, the crime-infested ghettos of the poor in the big cities.

The political elite is providing a lot of funding to these ghettos to keep people’s discontent there under some degree of control, but it is ignoring the far less unrest-prone portion of the population that has been forced out of the cities. Instead of occasionally rioting, this part of the population is increasingly supporting Marine Le Pen. Her statism is deemed to be attractive, because it promises security. In their boundless arrogance, France’s socialists simply blow off the voters of Ms. Le Pen as “stupid” (i.e., if only they weren’t so uneducated, they would surely support the socialists):


“The Socialists think Le Pen voters are stupid. When they say ‘these are people with not a single diploma’, what they mean is that if they were better educated, they’d vote for them,” Guilluy told the French version of online magazine, Slate. Le Pen’s avowedly statist solutions reassure those voters who feel that France’s declining economic situation mirrors their own. French schools have slipped in the global ratings, and fail some 150,000 children annually; the country’s vaunted infrastructure – trains, even the electrical grid – has started falling apart, because maintenance is neglected in favour of paying a workforce with golden contracts.


Mr Macron probably knows that a single tweet from his boss isn’t going to resolve the French malaise. When we elected Mr Hollande two and a half years ago, little did we know how fast things could deteriorate. Even hard-won economic success – in our case, Nicolas Sarkozy managing at least to keep things together and running during the financial crisis – can be reversed in moments. All of this feeds even more into the kind of malaise that may eventually get Miss Le Pen elected.”


(emphasis added)

We think it is rather distressing that the French seem set to exchange one form of statism for another, and one that might easily prove even worse. France was once home to truly great libertarian thinkers and free market economists like Turgot, Bastiat and de Molinari, to name just three of the most prominent. It is a great pity that the French have apparently forgotten the teachings of these men.


marine-le-penStrident right-wing statist Marine le Pen. Her economic program is Mercantilism pure.

(Screenshot via Reuters)


Nevertheless, Mr. Macron is a clear improvement over his predecessor. Whether the new cabinet under prime minister Valls, now that it has been reinforced by Macron, will be able to enact sufficiently far-reaching reforms to pull France out of its economic paralysis remains to be seen. As we have previously noted, the problem is that powerful vested interests from all walks of life as well as a combative workforce are all arrayed against any serious attempts at economic reform. It is even uncertain that the government can count on the support of its own party in parliament. In short, there is an ever greater chance that Ms. Le Pen will indeed come to power in the not-too-distant future.

As an aside, France’s establishment parties are involved in yet another political scandal revolving around ex-president Sarkozy and his recent political comeback efforts.



France continues to go downhill, and its political elites are seemingly too arrogant to recognize the dangers their policies have wrought. The population’s growing discontent could easily deliver a major wake-up call at the next general election, with a bang. However, no defender of the free market will replace the current crop of political leaders. Instead, yet more statism and economic regimentation await.


Addendum: Anne Robert Jacques Turgot

Readers interested in the writings and speeches of French statesman and economist Anne Robert Jacques Turgot can download a collection of his works for free here (pdf). Turgot is in many respects a “proto-Austrian” and we highly recommend this collection of his oeuvre.




Emigrate While You Can... Learn More




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


2 Responses to “France’s “Winter of Discontent””

  • Kreditanstalt:

    Hopeless. Sounds like most other G-7 economies…

    NO ONE will support any politician daring to state uncomfortable truths: living standards have to fall and personal responsibility for one’s own welfare must increasingly be accepted…

  • rodney:

    France was once home to truly great libertarian thinkers and free market economists like Turgot, Bastiat and de Molinari, to name just three of the most prominent.

    Important additions to that list: Jean Baptiste Say and Richard Cantillon (Irish French)

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • The Gold Debate – Where Do Things Stand in the Gold Market?
      A Recurring Pattern When the gold price recently spiked up to approach the resistance area even Aunt Hilda, Freddy the town drunk, and his blind dog know about by now, a recurring pattern played out. The move toward resistance fanned excitement among gold bugs (which was conspicuously lacking previously). This proved immediately self-defeating - prices pulled back right away, as they have done almost every time when the slightest bit of enthusiasm emerged in the sector in recent...
  • Monetary U-Turn: When Will the Fed Start Easing Again? Incrementum Advisory Board Meeting Q1 2019
      Special Guest Trey Reik and Board Member Jim Rickards Discuss Fed Policy On occasion of its Q1 meeting in late January, the Incrementum Advisory Board was joined by special guest Trey Reik, the lead portfolio manager of the Sprott Institutional Gold & Precious Metal Strategy at Sprott USA since 2015 [ed note: as always, a PDF of the complete transcript can be downloaded further below].   Trey Reik of Sprott USA.   Also at the meeting, Jim Rickards, who is inter...
  • Acting Man Returns - A Brief Housekeeping Note
      Pater Temporarily Keels Over Regular readers have no doubt noticed that the blog has fallen silent for around three weeks and may be wondering what has happened. In a nutshell, we were hospitalized. After a lengthy time period during which our health gradually but steadily deteriorated (we have complained about this previously), we finally keeled over. Thereupon we were forced to entrust the ruin that houses our mind to an experienced team of doctors (depicted below).   A...
  • Watch Europe - Free Pass for the Elliott Wave European Financial Forecast
      Europe at an Important Juncture European economic fundamentals have deteriorated rather noticeably over the past year - essentially ever since the German DAX Index topped out in January 2018. Now, European stock markets have reached an important juncture from a technical perspective. Consider the charts of the Euro-Stoxx 50 Index and the DAX shown below:   The Euro-Stoxx 50 Index already peaked in early November 2017, the DAX followed suit in January 2018 – such divergent peaks...
  • Why Warren Buffett Should Buy Gold
      Riding the Tailwinds of Fiat Money Inflation to Fame and Fortune Warren Buffett bought his first shares of stock when he was 11 years old.  He saved up $114.75 and “went all in,” purchasing three shares of Cities Service preferred stock.  The day was March 11, 1942 – nearly 77 years ago.  Buffett recently reminisced about this purchase in his annual letter to shareholders:   “I had become a capitalist, and it felt good.”   The Oracle of Omaha – he was...
  • Fake Money’s Face Value Deceit
      Not the Brightest Tool in the Shed Shane Anthony Mele stumbled off the straight and narrow path many years ago.  One bad decision here.  Another there.  And he was neck deep in the smelly stuff. These missteps compounded over the years and also magnified his natural shortcomings.  Namely, that he’s a thief and – to be polite – a moron.   Over-educated he ain't: Shane Anthony Mele, whose expressive mug was captured by a Florida police photographer first in...
  • Rise of the Zombies - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Rise of the Zombies - Precious Metals Supply and Demand Last week, the prices of gold and silver fell $35 and ¢70, respectively. But what does that mean (other than woe unto anyone who owned silver futures with leverage)? The S&P 500 index and the euro was up a bit, though the yuan was flat and copper was down. Most notably, the spread between Treasury and junk yields fell. If the central banks can lower the risk of default premium, they can make everything unicorns and...
  • Bitcoin Bottom Building
      Defending 3,800 and a Swing Trade Play For one week, bulls have been defending the 3,800 USD value area with success. But on March 4th they had to give way to the constant pressure. Prices fell quickly to the 3,700 USD level. These extended times of range bound trading are typical for Bitcoin Bottom Building in sideways ranges. This 60 minute chart of Bitcoin shows (represented by the yellow candlestick wicks) how the bulls defended 3,800 USD :   BTCUSDT 60 minute chart...
  • The Magic Doesn't Always Work - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      The Week Ends with a Surprise The weekly closing prices of the precious metals were up +$5 and +¢11. But this does not tell the full story of the trading action. Prices were dropping until Friday. More precisely, Friday 8am in New York, or 1pm in London.   Gold and silver - back in demand on Friday... [PT]   At that moment, a light cabal conspiring to jack the price struck traders began buying. The end result was the prices, especially of silver, rose on the day...
  • Intraweek Profit Opportunities
      In 6 of 10 Countries a Single Day Outperforms the Entire Week! In the Seasonal Insights issue of 13 February 2019 I presented a study illustrating the power of intraweek effects. The article was entitled “S&P 500 Index: A Single Day Beats the Entire Week!” The result of the study: if one had been invested exclusively during a single day of the week since 2000  – namely on Tuesday – one would have outperformed a buy and hold strategy, beating the broad market. Moreover,...

Support Acting Man

Item Guides

Austrian Theory and Investment


The Review Insider


Dog Blow


THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from]


Mish Talk

Buy Silver Now!
Buy Gold Now!