A New Variation of the 'Cleanest Dirty Shirt' Theory

Bill Gross has for some time forwarded the theory that the US was doing better relative to other regions in the post 2008 crisis era because it was the owner of the 'cleanest dirty shirt'. This was specifically in reference to US treasury bonds, which time and again have proven to attract 'safe haven flows' when trouble erupted elsewhere.

Following the sizable decline in stocks late last week, others are now trying to expand this theory to the US stock market in the wake of the rout in emerging market currencies:


“The ongoing concerns about emerging markets could end up boosting U.S. stocks as investors look for greener pastures, BMO's Brian Belski told CNBC on Monday.

Belski, chief investment strategist at BMO Capital Markets, said the jitters that caused ripples across global stock markets last week stem from a redeployment of cash between emerging markets and the next investment opportunity. As currencies in emerging markets such as Argentina, Turkey and South Africa continue to falter, the U.S. stock market could be the next best option for investors, he said.

"That's why people are freaking out," Belski said on "Squawk Box." "When you think about asset cycles, the last cycle was driven by credit. The current investment cycle has been driven by cash. … Which companies in the world have the strongest balance sheets in cash? It's America."

Michael Purves, chief global strategist at Weeden & Co., agreed that the ongoing worries over emerging market currencies could bode well for U.S. Equities. Multinational companies that do large amounts of business in developing countries, however, could have trouble if those nations continue to appear unstable, he said.”



(emphasis added)

Allow us to point out here that somehow, the US dollar hasn't been told about this. Emerging market currencies can be said to have been in a kind of 'rolling crisis' since the Indian rupee more or less crashed in the summer of 2013 (note that it has been in a downtrend since late 2011, which morphed into a rout last year). Over the same time period, the US dollar index actually went down. Admittedly, not by much (it got a lot of help from the weakening yen), but it sure hasn't been reflective of the idea that the US has been the prime destination of international capital flows.

Further below we will briefly discuss a historical occasion when the above suggestion actually 'worked' in a way, but at the time the dollar was in a rising trend. This time it has proved spectacularly incapable of profiting from currency turmoil elsewhere. Among the major currencies, the euro has turned out to be the strongest over this time stretch (it was officially declared dead by Newsweek on May 17, 2011, and again on July 2012, which was a rather big hint that the funerary rites had to be postponed). Not only that, European stock markets, long underperforming, have outperformed the SPX as well in the second half of 2013.



100507 NewsweekEuropeanEdition

Newsweek cover, May 17 2011 – this could be called 'Newsweek trying to save the euro by noticing the currency's downtrend exactly three weeks before it reversed again'



Newsweek-juny_ARAIMA20120614_0059_1Newsweek trying to save the euro again in June 2012 – so far it has worked surprisingly well (with support from at least two 'Economist' cover stories along the way)



DXYTurbulence in emerging market currencies as well as a weak yen have failed to buoy the dollar index – click to enlarge.



It Once Worked …

To be fair, there have been occasions when the idea of emerging market troubles lifting US stocks actually kind of 'worked' in a sense (provided one believes enormous stock market bubbles are indicative of things 'working' as they should). For instance, the 1997-1998 Asian/Russian crisis produced a mini crash in the US stock market in 1997 and a somewhat more serious crash in 1998. Following the second event, the market went on to a bubble-like advance that saw the Nasdaq index go parabolic (it went from a low of less than 1,400 points in October 1998 to a high above 5,000 points in March of 2000, easily one of the biggest stock market bubbles ever witnessed in such a short time span).




The Nasdaq Composite from the summer of 1998 to Q1 2000 – one of the biggest  stock market manias of all time started with an emerging markets crisis – click to enlarge.



Apart from the fact that the US dollar index was actually rising at the time, two other things are worth pointing about this previous occasion. First of all, before the US stock market was able to 'benefit' from turmoil elsewhere, it crashed. The 1998 crash was actually quite a scary event (most observers certainly agreed that systemic risk was rearing its head at the time) and definitely wiped out the excess bullish sentiment that was in evidence earlier that year. The decline also happened to reduce outstanding margin debt considerably.

Secondly, the eventual rally was triggered by repeated interest rate cuts by the Federal Reserve, including an inter-meeting 'surprise cut' in October 1998 on options expiration day, for maximum effect (sellers of calls were forced to delta-hedge as the market exploded into their face in the final hour of trading, producing a huge one day rise that proved to be the 'kick-off' to the rally that followed).

When considering the current situation, we must first of all note that the market has not (yet) crashed and that sentiment remains quite complacent – as the above article excerpt actually confirms. Margin debt definitely has not had a chance to reach sensible levels, quite on the contrary, it has reached a new record high. Not only that, but the negative net worth of investors finally slightly exceeds the record that was set at the peak of the tech stock mania in 2000 (or putting it differently: investors using margin are now more dependent on a continuation of the rally than ever before in history. The market rarely obliges in such situations and if it does, it usually won't be for long).



margin debt

Every aspect of margin debt has reached new record levels – this demonstrates the current extremes of bullish sentiment quite starkly – click to enlarge.



Monetary Policy Inertia

Finally, one wonders what interest rate the Fed is supposed to cut this time around. With the federal funds rate already at zero, effectively only a reversal of the 'QE tapering' course could be in the offing at some point (in fact, we believe this will eventually happen), but one must not forget that Fed policy is subject to a great deal of inertia. It is always reactive – i.e., the Fed is generally trying to close the barn door long after the horse has escaped, whether it is by means of tightening or easing monetary policy.

The Fed is moreover the one place in the world where one can find what is quite likely the biggest congregation of 'always wrong' forecasters. Meteorologists (though not, we should add, climatologists) are founts of remarkable forecasting accuracy by comparison. Hence its policies are actually never forward-looking, and even if they were, the entire effort would still be no better than throwing dice. Occasionally its inept bungling from crisis to crisis is masked by sheer luck, but in essence this bureaucracy represents a monument to the long known fact that central economic planning simply does not work.

Having just begun the 'QE taper', the above mentioned inertia almost guarantees that the policy will be continued for a while yet and that it will indeed require a lot more turbulence in the market for it to be altered again. That is however a crucial point for those who express the view that crises elsewhere will prove 'supportive for US stocks'. They will only if and when monetary pumping re-accelerates, and  even then there can be no guarantee, as much will depend on the state of the economy's pool of real funding, the demand for money, and other not yet foreseeable and inherently unmeasurable contingent circumstances.

Lastly, it is always possible that emerging markets will calm down again and that the market remains unperturbed for a while longer. As noted yesterday, an initial sharp decline is often merely a 'warning shot'. This scenario would postpone a denouement, but would make it even more likely that it will be painful, as money supply growth would have more time to continue to slow down.

We should also mention again that the idea expressed by one of the analysts quoted above that 'US corporations have so much cash' is slightly misleading. First of all, cash holdings are very unevenly distributed – the vast bulk of this cash is held by just a handful of corporations. Secondly, corporate debt has grown even faster than cash hoards, which means that the aggregate corporate net cash position has actually worsened.



While in the spirit of 'all news is bullish' that has been so pervasive throughout 2013, it is highly doubtful that the idea that a crisis in emerging markets is also bullish will turn out to hold water. That is actually tortured logic. If the crisis continues or worsens, it may be bullish for US treasury bonds and other 'safe haven' assets, but certainly not for stocks.


Addendum: More Trend Line Breaks

We pointed out yesterday that the Nasdaq and Russell indexes had not yet broken their short term uptrend lines as of Friday – this changed on Monday, as both indexes played 'catch up'. We still don't regard these declines as particularly large or meaningful from a technical perspective, but they certainly could be the harbinger of worse to come down the road.



Charts by: StockCharts, BigCharts, Sentimentrader




Emigrate While You Can... Learn More




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


2 Responses to “The Search for Improbable Scenarios”

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • The Gold Debate – Where Do Things Stand in the Gold Market?
      A Recurring Pattern When the gold price recently spiked up to approach the resistance area even Aunt Hilda, Freddy the town drunk, and his blind dog know about by now, a recurring pattern played out. The move toward resistance fanned excitement among gold bugs (which was conspicuously lacking previously). This proved immediately self-defeating - prices pulled back right away, as they have done almost every time when the slightest bit of enthusiasm emerged in the sector in recent...
  • Monetary U-Turn: When Will the Fed Start Easing Again? Incrementum Advisory Board Meeting Q1 2019
      Special Guest Trey Reik and Board Member Jim Rickards Discuss Fed Policy On occasion of its Q1 meeting in late January, the Incrementum Advisory Board was joined by special guest Trey Reik, the lead portfolio manager of the Sprott Institutional Gold & Precious Metal Strategy at Sprott USA since 2015 [ed note: as always, a PDF of the complete transcript can be downloaded further below].   Trey Reik of Sprott USA.   Also at the meeting, Jim Rickards, who is inter...
  • Acting Man Returns - A Brief Housekeeping Note
      Pater Temporarily Keels Over Regular readers have no doubt noticed that the blog has fallen silent for around three weeks and may be wondering what has happened. In a nutshell, we were hospitalized. After a lengthy time period during which our health gradually but steadily deteriorated (we have complained about this previously), we finally keeled over. Thereupon we were forced to entrust the ruin that houses our mind to an experienced team of doctors (depicted below).   A...
  • Watch Europe - Free Pass for the Elliott Wave European Financial Forecast
      Europe at an Important Juncture European economic fundamentals have deteriorated rather noticeably over the past year - essentially ever since the German DAX Index topped out in January 2018. Now, European stock markets have reached an important juncture from a technical perspective. Consider the charts of the Euro-Stoxx 50 Index and the DAX shown below:   The Euro-Stoxx 50 Index already peaked in early November 2017, the DAX followed suit in January 2018 – such divergent peaks...
  • Why Warren Buffett Should Buy Gold
      Riding the Tailwinds of Fiat Money Inflation to Fame and Fortune Warren Buffett bought his first shares of stock when he was 11 years old.  He saved up $114.75 and “went all in,” purchasing three shares of Cities Service preferred stock.  The day was March 11, 1942 – nearly 77 years ago.  Buffett recently reminisced about this purchase in his annual letter to shareholders:   “I had become a capitalist, and it felt good.”   The Oracle of Omaha – he was...
  • Fake Money’s Face Value Deceit
      Not the Brightest Tool in the Shed Shane Anthony Mele stumbled off the straight and narrow path many years ago.  One bad decision here.  Another there.  And he was neck deep in the smelly stuff. These missteps compounded over the years and also magnified his natural shortcomings.  Namely, that he’s a thief and – to be polite – a moron.   Over-educated he ain't: Shane Anthony Mele, whose expressive mug was captured by a Florida police photographer first in...
  • Rise of the Zombies - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Rise of the Zombies - Precious Metals Supply and Demand Last week, the prices of gold and silver fell $35 and ¢70, respectively. But what does that mean (other than woe unto anyone who owned silver futures with leverage)? The S&P 500 index and the euro was up a bit, though the yuan was flat and copper was down. Most notably, the spread between Treasury and junk yields fell. If the central banks can lower the risk of default premium, they can make everything unicorns and...
  • Bitcoin Bottom Building
      Defending 3,800 and a Swing Trade Play For one week, bulls have been defending the 3,800 USD value area with success. But on March 4th they had to give way to the constant pressure. Prices fell quickly to the 3,700 USD level. These extended times of range bound trading are typical for Bitcoin Bottom Building in sideways ranges. This 60 minute chart of Bitcoin shows (represented by the yellow candlestick wicks) how the bulls defended 3,800 USD :   BTCUSDT 60 minute chart...
  • The Magic Doesn't Always Work - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      The Week Ends with a Surprise The weekly closing prices of the precious metals were up +$5 and +¢11. But this does not tell the full story of the trading action. Prices were dropping until Friday. More precisely, Friday 8am in New York, or 1pm in London.   Gold and silver - back in demand on Friday... [PT]   At that moment, a light cabal conspiring to jack the price struck traders began buying. The end result was the prices, especially of silver, rose on the day...
  • Intraweek Profit Opportunities
      In 6 of 10 Countries a Single Day Outperforms the Entire Week! In the Seasonal Insights issue of 13 February 2019 I presented a study illustrating the power of intraweek effects. The article was entitled “S&P 500 Index: A Single Day Beats the Entire Week!” The result of the study: if one had been invested exclusively during a single day of the week since 2000  – namely on Tuesday – one would have outperformed a buy and hold strategy, beating the broad market. Moreover,...

Support Acting Man

Item Guides

Austrian Theory and Investment


The Review Insider


Dog Blow


THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]


Mish Talk

Buy Silver Now!
Buy Gold Now!